Dumbarton vs Dundee

Share this story
  • Report
  • Stats
  • Live commentary
Date: 06 February 2016
Venue: The Cheaper Insurance Direct Stadium
Competition: William Hill Scottish Cup


0 - 0


Dundee were held to a frustrating goalless draw by their battling hosts Dumbarton in the Scottish Cup 5th round this afternoon. The Dark Blues failed to capitalise on their dominance in a one sided first half, then couldn't break down the Sons in a scrappy second half on a poor pitch that spoilt the match.

Dundee sent out an unchanged line-up after the draw against Motherwell. Dumbarton made two changes; Barr and ex-Dee Christian Nadé replacing Lindsay and Cawley.

The Dark Blues started strongly, taking control and remaining in charge for the rest of the first half. Dundee came agonisingly close to taking the lead in the fourth minute. Greg Stewart patiently held the ball after a corner came back to him. He found Nick Ross, who took a touch before crashing a low drive off the post from 18 yards. Rory Loy followed up but Jamie Ewings saved his shot.

Dundee kept pressing and looked dangerous with every attack. Gary Harkins went close with a long range effort, and forced Ewings to punch away a 25 yard free kick.

Scott Bain was barely in the game in the first half, apart from taking goal kicks and the occasional free kick for offside. The Dee keeper did have to move smartly off his line to cover, however, when Nadé charged down a clearance. The Sons' French striker was well received by the Dee support, but he was often left stranded on his own up front. Dumbarton were sitting deep in defence, often having 10 men back in the final third.

Dundee had a succession of corners that they failed to make the most of. The heavy pitch made it hard to play a passing game and the mud came to Dumbarton's rescue late in the first half. A fast move between Stewart and Loy released Kane Hemmings. The Dee's top scorer slipped the ball past Ewings, only for it to slow up as it bounced towards the net and Mark Docherty's frantic sprint was rewarded when he made a goal-saving clearance off the line.

As the game wore on into the second half the pitch became even worse, cutting up badly. The Dee kept trying to pass their way through Dumbarton's defence, but too often their moves broke down in the mud. Hemmings did place the ball in the net after a neat passing move that did work, but he was offside. Another good move ended with Ewings saving McGowan's 18 yard shot.

In a rare Sons' attack Docherty curled a shot well wide after Darren O'Dea had put the Dee under pressure with a careless pass out of defence. Apart from that Dumbarton were restricted to a couple of wayward long rane shots.

The Dark Blues might have struggled to click in the difficult conditions, but Dumbarton deserve great credit for their hard work and defensive organisation. Harkins did go close when he glanced a header over the bar from Stewart's corner, but the Dark Blues seldom looked dangerous from their many set piece opportunities.

Arturo replaced Loy for the last 20 minutes and quickly linked with Stewart to set up Loy, whose angled drive was saved by Ewings. Arturo had a go himself from Loy's cutback, but Ewings saved again.

After digging in and surviving for the first 80 minutes the Sons moved forward to try and nick a winner towards the end. They had a dangerous wee surge, but failed to create any chances or force Bain to make a save.

Dundee pushed hard for a winner in the last few minutes, but they lacked the composure required to break down Dumbarton's defence. Kevin Holt went close after winning the ball in the penalty area, and Greg Stewart volleyed wide from 18 yards.

A tricky away cup tie on a poor pitch could easily have ended very badly. A draw might be frustrating but at least the Dee are still in the cup. If Dundee's early dominance had given them the lead they might have won this game comfortably, but the Sons dug in, kept battling and kept their concentration. They deserve their second chance, but the Dark Blues will feel they should really have won this tie without a replay at Dens.

Dumbarton FC 4-1-4-1

Saunders, Buchanan, Wright, Docherty
Fleming, Routledge, Gallagher (Taggart 80), Walsh
Nadé (Cawley 75)

Unused subs: Brown (gk), Kirkpatrick, McCallum, Waters, Heh

Booked: Wright (foul on Stewart)

Dundee FC 4-2-3-1

McGinn, O'Dea, Konrad, Holt
McGowan, Ross (Arturo 71)
Stewart, Harkins, Loy (Low 78)

Unused subs: Mitchell (gk), Etxabeguren, Gadzhalov, Kerr, Wighton

Booked: O'Dea (dissent)

Referee: Stephen Finnie. Assistants: Willie Conquer, Joseph Lawson. 4th official: Barry Cook.

Attendance: 1410

Report: James Christie



Total Shots


On Target










  • Ewings, Docherty, Saunders, Buchanan, Barr, Gallagher, Fleming, Routledge, Nade, Wright, Walsh,


  • Bain, Holt, Konrad, Stewart, Loy, Hemmings, Ross, McGowan, McGinn, O'Dea, Harkins


0 - 0

Sat 06th Feb 3:00pm


16:49 Dundee dominated a difficult game on a difficult pitch but we'll have to do it all again at Dens
16:49 Full time
16:47 Stewart shoots just wide from the edge of the box
16:46 Wright heads an Arturo cross behind for a corner
16:44 Holt fizzes a shot just wide from just inside the box
16:39 O'Dea is booked for arguing with the ref after conceding a foul on half way line. He had been warned in the first half
16:38 Dumbarton sub: Gallagher off, Taggart on
16:37 Dundee sub: Loy off, Low on
16:35 Referee blows for a foul to Dumbaton as soon as Harkins takes the free kick
16:34 Buchanan booked for tripping Stewart as he ran towards goal
16:32 Arturo shoots straight at keeper from 12 yards
16:32 Dumbarton sub: Nade off, Cawley on
16:31 Gallagher shot from edge of box well over the bar
16:30 Arturo slides in on Routledge and concedes a foul
16:29 Loy shot from 10 yards saved by Ewings
16:24 Dundee sub: Arturo on, Ross off
16:23 Harkins heads Stewart's corner just over the bar
16:22 Loy slips as he was about to shoot and Wright puts ball behind for Dundee's 11th corner
16:21 Stewart free kick into the box headed away by Saunders
16:21 Docherty trips Loy in middle of Dumbarton's half
16:16 Docherty bends an effort just wide of Bain's left hand post for their first shot of the game
16:16 Harkins free kick headed out the box by Barr
16:15 Buchanan takes down Stewart out wide 25 yards from goal
16:15 Nade is inches away from connecting with a Walsh cross to the back post
16:12 McGowan shot from edge of box saved by Ewings
16:11 Hemmings puts the ball in the net after being played in by Stewart but the flag is up for offside
16:07 Stewart low cross into the box booted clear by Saunders
16:06 Stewart has a clear sight of goal after a wonderful pass from Harkins but Buchanan tackles him
16:05 Docherty takes the ball off Loy just as he is swinging his leg to shoot
16:04 Harkins hits the free kick straight into the wall
16:02 Barr brings down Harkins on the right of the D in a central position
16:02 Second half underway
16:00 Dundee to kick off
15:59 Dumbarton are back out now
15:45 Dundee are back out
15:44 Half time
15:44 Harkins corner sails over everyone and out for a goal kick
15:43 Corner falls to McGowan at the edge of the box and his shot is deflected wide for another corner
15:42 Stewart cross from the left deflected behind for a corner
15:40 Stewart bundles over in middle of Sons' half
15:39 Nade is clear on goal but Ross rushes back to disposes him on the edge of the box
15:37 McGowan cross is too hard and goal out for a goal kick
15:36 Hemmings is through on goal and clips it over the keeper but Docherty rushes in and clears it just off the line
15:34 Fleming heads Holt cross out of the Dumbarton box
15:33 Dundee play the corner short but can't fashion a chance and lose possession
15:32 Routledge dives to head Hemmings cross out for a corner
15:32 As the corner comes over ref blows for a foul to Dumbarton, pointing at Konrad
15:31 Wright heads Harkins corner out for another corner
15:31 Nade tackles Loy at the corner flag to concede a corner
15:30 McGowan cross field ball too hard for Holt
15:29 McGinn plays ball to Stewart just inside the box but he loses control and Docherty clears
15:29 Ross twice blocks a Barr shot at the edge of Dundee's box
15:28 O'Dea brings down Nade in the middle of Dundee's half from behind
15:26 Bain long kick runs through to his opposite number Ewings
15:26 Routledge heads away a Stewart cross out of the box
15:25 Barr heads Stewart corner away at front post
15:24 Great run by Steart down the right and he wins corner off Docherty
15:21 Stewart tries to play in Hemmings after some patient build up but it runs through to Ewings
15:21 Bain races off his line to clear before Nade
15:20 Routledge clips McGowan's heels just inside Dundee half
15:20 Stewart pushes Docherty over at the edge of the Dumbarton box as they challenge for a high ball
15:19 Gallagher runs down the right wing but O'Dea shadows him as he runs it out for a Dundee goal kick
15:17 Holt takes the ball off Nade and clears upfield but it runs through to Ewings
15:17 Harkins corner goes over everyone and out for a goal kick at the opposite side
15:16 Loy wins corner off Buchanan
15:15 Stewart runs from his own half to the edge of the box before Wright tackles him
15:14 Harkins free kick is punched away by Ewings
15:11 O'Dea charges forward and is brought down right on the edge of the box
15:10 Ross shot from edge of box trickles just wide
15:09 Stewart free kick into the box goes straight to Ewings on goal
15:09 Gallagher penalised for a high foot on Stewart in the middle of Dumbarton's half
15:08 McGinn wins a throw in down by the corner flag
15:08 Stewart tries to dunk a ball into the box but Walsh heads it away
15:07 Loy and then Stewart have a shot but both efforts blocked by Routledge
15:05 Wright clears a Hemmings ball into the six yard box before Stewart
15:04 Ross smacks the ball off the post from the edge of the box and Loy hits the rebound into the keeper's arms
15:04 Buchanan heads Stewart behind
15:03 Buchanan puts a McGinn cross behind for a corner
15:02 Saunders heads a high Stewart ball back to his keeper
15:00 Hemmings runs into the box but Barr tackles him and clears
15:00 Game underway
15:00 Dumbarton to kick off
14:59 Dundee wearing an all blue kit while Dumbarton wearing their all white home kit of
14:59 Here come the teams
14:28 Dundee have former Son Paul McGinn in their team while Dumarton have former Dee Christain Nade in their starting line up
14:24 Harkins continues to captain Dundee while Darren Barr captains The Sons
14:24 The pitch doesn't look the best
14:08 It's a miserable wet afternoon in Dunbartonshire
14:07 Assistant Referees are Willie Conquer and Joseph Lawson. Fourth official Barry Cook
14:05 Today's referee is Stephen Finnie
14:04 Dumbarton subs: Brown, Taggart, Kirkpatrick, Cawley, McCallum, Waters, Heh
14:00 Dumbarton starting XI: Ewings, Docherty, Saunders, Buchanan, Barr, Gallagher, Fleming, Routledge, Nade, Wright, Walsh,
14:00 Dundee subs: Mitchell, Etxabeguren, Low, Wighton, Kerr, Arturo, Gadhalov
13:58 Dundee starting XI: Bain, Holt, Konrad, Stewart, Loy, Hemmings, Ross, McGowan, McGinn, O'Dea, Harkins
13:57 Welcome to The Cheaper Insurance Direct Stadium for the William Hill Scottish Cup 5th Round match between Dumbarton or Dundee
Back to Match Reports
Share this story